By Simon Kershaw | Posted on May 09, 2025 4:30 PM
What Broadway Shows Have Sold Out Of All Their Tickets This Month: Sold-Out Shows For May 2025
What Broadway Shows Have Sold 100% Of Their Tickets This Month?
Sold-Out Broadway Shows For May 2025
The following Broadway shows are playing to packed audiences and have sold out every single ticket at every performance - this may indicate that their ticket pricing may increase as producers increase ticket prices. This perfect-score ticket sales performance does not mean they are actually the best shows on Broadway, just that they sold all their tickets.
1 - Good Night, and Good Luck
Stage Production of Clooney's Oscar-Nominated 2005 film, Set in the 1950's As Murrow Goes Up Against Senator Joseph McCarthy During The McCarthy Hearings
Average Ticket Price: $315.52
Top Ticket Price: $805.00
Seats Sold: 12538
Gross Ticket Sales: $3,955,968.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
2 - Othello
A timeless tale of jealousy, manipulation, and tragic downfall unfolds once again on Broadway, but this time with powerhouses Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal in the lead roles
Average Ticket Price: $384.23
Top Ticket Price: $897.00
Seats Sold: 8344
Gross Ticket Sales: $3,206,029.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
3 - Wicked
The prequel of The Wizard of Oz where Elphaba becomes the Wicked Witch of the West. Based on the 1995 original novel by Gregory Maguire.
Average Ticket Price: $138.67
Top Ticket Price: $352.00
Seats Sold: 15408
Gross Ticket Sales: $2,136,597.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
4 - The Picture Of Dorian Gray
One-handed stage adaptation of Oscar Wilde’s novel where Gray's pursuit of eternal youth corrupts his soul; his portrait ages and decays while he remains physically unscathed
Average Ticket Price: $189.02
Top Ticket Price: $497.00
Seats Sold: 7008
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,324,626.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
5 - Buena Vista Social Club
Brings to life the story of Cuban music legends, showcasing their captivating performances, rich rhythms, and the enduring spirit of Cuban culture in pre-Castro Cuba.
Average Ticket Price: $142.51
Top Ticket Price: $475.00
Seats Sold: 8393
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,196,100.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
6 - The Outsiders
Two rival teenage groups, from different socio-economic backgrounds, navigate the tensions and violence that arise between them, ultimately leading to tragic events.
Average Ticket Price: $142.15
Top Ticket Price: $398.00
Seats Sold: 8192
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,164,484.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
7 - Just in Time
Chronicles Bobby Darin’s journey to stardom, his turbulent personal life, marriage to Sandra Dee, and timeless songs.
Average Ticket Price: $204.36
Top Ticket Price: $496.50
Seats Sold: 5682
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,161,166.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
8 - Oh, Mary!
Campy comedic play that examines a fictitious life of Mary Todd Lincoln who is miserable in the weeks leading up to Abraham Lincoln’s assassination and suffers from an unrequited yearning, alcoholism and suppressed sexual desires.
Average Ticket Price: $154.25
Top Ticket Price: $375.00
Seats Sold: 7160
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,104,396.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
9 - Maybe Happy Ending
A robot that has long been retired (and is now considered obsolete) meets his neighbor robot and what starts as an awkward encounter leads to a unique friendship, a surprising adventure, and maybe even…love?
Average Ticket Price: $127.78
Top Ticket Price: $425.00
Seats Sold: 7862
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,004,624.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
10 - John Proctor Is the Villain
Play that explores high school students grappling with gender, power, and morality, paralleling themes from Arthur Miller's The Crucible, amid personal revelations.
Average Ticket Price: $100.97
Top Ticket Price: $375.00
Seats Sold: 6283
Gross Ticket Sales: $634,363.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
Sold-Out Status Is Not What It Used To Be
Even though the above Broadway shows have sold every single ticket that were available, making the show effectively sold-out, this does not mean that they are the most popular tickets on Broadway. That criteria is defined by the gross tickets sales value, instead of percentage-sold tickets.
A Broadway show may give many tickets away for free (or practically nothing) to get classified as "sold-out" - which then allows them to advertise the show as "sold-out" to increase ticket sales on the back end of the run. Its disingenuous at best, and deceiving at worst - but a lot of Broadway shows still do it.
See all Discount Broadway Show tickets
