Summer: The Donna Summer Musical opened to negative reviews at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, even though it shares a director with the hit jukebox musical Jersey Boys.

Des McAnuff Directs Donna Summer Jukebox Musical

Summer Broadway Show
On April 23, 2018, Summer: The Donna Summer Musical opened at the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, where it had been running in previews since March 28, 2018. This show is the latest in the trend of jukebox musicals, a genre that has had its share of hits and flops. Perhaps the greatest jukebox musical success story is Jersey Boys, the show featuring the music of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, which ran on Broadway from 2005 to 2017 and still has a national tour ongoing, won the 2006 Tony Award for Best Musical and the 2009 Olivier Award for Best Musical, and was adapted into a 2014 feature film directed by Clint Eastwood. That show was directed by Des McAnuff, who returns to Broadway with this new jukebox musical, featuring the songs of Donna Summer. Unfortunately, based on the mixed to negative reviews that just came in following the show’s opening night, it does not appear that Summer will reach anywhere near the hit status of the Jersey Boys glory. Summer has a book by Colman Domingo, Robert Cary, and Des McAnuff, with songs by Donna Summer, Giorgio Moroder, and Paul Jabara, and choreography by Sergio Trujillo. Three different ladies star as Donna Summer in different times of her life: Ariana DeBose as Disco Donna, LaChanze as Diva Donna, and Storm Lever as Duckling Donna.

Largely Negative Reviews from Major Critics

In response to seeing the show prior to opening night, Jesse Green from The New York Times called the show a “blight.” While he admitted to enjoying the “exciting vocalism” of the performers, specifically shouting out LaChanze, he despised how the show “reduces the late Queen of Disco and pioneer of electronica to a few factoids and song samples that make her seem profoundly inconsequential.” David Rooney from The Hollywood Reporter was also disappointed by the musical, calling it “a tacky little show, a feebly dramatized Wikipedia page with lackluster covers, which was rushed to Broadway following a fall tryout at La Jolla Playhouse that received mostly tepid reviews.” Greg Evans from Deadline agreed that the show left much to be desired, deeming it “as unimaginative as its title,” but he did admit to “the saving graces of really fine vocal performances from LaChanze, Ariana DeBose and young Storm Lever.” Breanne L. Heldman from Entertainment Weekly was more on the fence, beginning with the upbeat comment that Summer “delivers seasonal sunshine,” and that “if you’re lookin’ for some hot stuff on Broadway, you’ve come to the right place.” However, she also qualifies that by saying that the show lacks depth. Still, she mentioned how he audience broke out in song to sing along with their favorite tunes. Matt Windman from AM New York began with an allusion to the same song as his colleague at Entertainment Weekly, but took it another direction, saying: “Lookin’ for some hot stuff baby this evenin’? Look somewhere other than the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre.”

Modest Box Office Performance

Despite these negative reviews, there is still an audience for jukebox musicals from beloved musical artists. In the case of Summer, the demand is not overwhelming, but it is greater than one would expect from the reviews alone. Whether this demand sustains remains to be seen, and awards season will not likely add to the ticket-buying motivation. In the last week of box office figures, the week ending April 22, 2018, Summer brought in $962,917, which represents 66.15% of its gross potential. With a top ticket price of $197.00, the average paid admission was $87.94, and the audience was filled up to 93.1% of capacity. Over the course of the four weeks of figures reported thus far, the average percentage reached of gross potential has been 68.70%, and the average audience capacity has been 87.65%. As such, there is a fair amount of discounting, and still the houses aren’t full. Chances are that Summer may not last too many months beyond this upcoming summer tourist season.