It Shoulda Been You on Broadway: Show Is Now Closed

Regular Price Tickets
Icon Image
Secondary Market

It Shoulda Been You Summary

  • Show Status: Closed
  • Genre: Musical
  • It Shoulda Been You is 1.5 Hours long, including an intermission of None
  • 8 Shows per week
  • Previews Began: March 17, 2015
  • Show Opened : April 14, 2015
  • Show Closed: August 9, 2015

It Shoulda Been You is a charming and hilarious musical romp set during a wedding in which cultures collide. When two families are joined that have very different backgrounds, plots are made and secrets are revealed. The mix of religions of the parents-of-the-happy-couple in this Broadway musical result in a hysterical wedding-from-hell.

It Shoulda Been You on Broadway Background

This delightful musical about a wedding in a mixed religion family, first premiered at the George Street Playhouse in 2011 and has now found its way to Broadway. Directed by David Hyde Pierce ("Frasier"), It Shoulda Been You stars Tyne Daly (Master Class) in the role of the matriarch Judy Steinberg, who is the Jewish mother of the bride. Harriet Harris (Cinderella) is the Protestant mother of the groom. The show also stars Sierra Boggess (The Little Mermaid, The Phantom of the Opera), and David Burtka (Gypsy). The show was conceived by Barbara Anselmi with book and lyrics by Brian Hargrove, and additional lyrics by Jill Abramowitz. The show is choreographed by Noah Racey and music direction is by David Loud. Rife with interreligious jest, the dynamic of the parental in-laws and their deeply embedded xenophobic beliefs provides a story that many married couples could find relation to.

What's It Shoulda Been You Like?

While the theme is not exactly unique, as many romantic comedies include the dichotomy between parents and their children’s prospective bride or groom to be. The bride’s sister is held responsible for turning what could be a disaster into a heartwarming conclusion. The score has a number of charming songs that bring out the comedy in family conflict. On an interesting note, the show’s creative team includes a number of famous gay theatre couples, such as David Hyde Pierce (the director) and Brian Hargrove (the composer), as well as David Burtka (the bridegroom), who is the husband of Neil Patrick Harris (Hedwig and the Angry Inch).

Is It Shoulda Been You Good for Kids?

The show may be inappropriate for children under the age of 10, due to themes of sexuality. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theatre.

Theatre Information

Lena Horne Theatre

256 West 47th Street
New York, NY 10019
Seats: 1,109
Entrance: 47th Street between Broadway and 8th Avenue
Theatre Information

Lena Horne Theatre Seating Chart

Cast Members

Sierra Boggess
David Burtka
Tyne Daly
Josh Grisetti
Montego Glover
Harriet Harris
Edward Hibbert


Daryl Roth

Scott Landis

Jayne Baron Sherman

Jane Bergere

John O'Boyle

Production Credits

David Hyde Pierce
Scenic Designer
Anna Louizos
Costume Designer
William Ivey Long
Lighting Designer
Ken Billington
Sound Designer
Nevin Steinberg
Brian Hargrove
Additional Lyrics
Jill Abramovitz + Carla Rose Fisher + Michael Cooper + Ernie Lijoi + Will Randall
Brian Hargrove
Barbara Anselmi
Production Stage Manager
Bess Marie Glorioso

Creative Team

General Manager
Foresight Theatrical LLC
Technical Supervisor
Juniper Street Productions
Casting Director
Tara Rubin Casting
Advertising Representative
Serino Coyne
Press Agent
O&M Co