All Out: Comedy About Ambition

Simon Rich’s high-grossing Broadway hit All In: Comedy About Love, was such a huge success that its producers are trying to make lightning strike twice with a follow-up show All Out: Comedy About Ambition for the 2025-2026 season. This new production, expands its scope from love stories to broader tales about life, once again written by Simon Rich and originally published in The New Yorker.

The First Show Set High Ticket Pricing RecordSet New Record

All In was directed by Alex Timbers and the production set a new record for the highest-grossing week for a play at the Hudson, a milestone reached the week ending February 2, 2025. All Out: Comedy About Ambition is trying to break that record.

Nine Week Production

All Out is expected to go down the same route as All In did, with overpriced tickets and a short production window of nine weeks to maximize profit, to create buyer interest - but audiences may now be wise to this pitch which could be why the producers did not announce the show before All In closed. 

Many ticket buyers thought that this was their last chance to see the line up together - but it looks like they are now doing it all over again and buyers will not be fleeced so easily the second time around.

Rotating List of Big-Name Performers

• Eric André - December 12 – December 28, 2025
• Jim Gaffigan December 12, 2025 – January 11, 2026
• Abbi Jacobson December 12 – December 28, 2025
• Jon Stewart December 12 – December 21, 2025
• Ben Schwartz December 22, 2025 – January 11, 2026
• Wayne Brady December 29, 2025 – January 18, 2026
• Cecily Strong December 29, 2025 – January 18, 2026
• Mike Birbiglia January 13 – January 18, 2026
• Heidi Gardner January 20 – February 15, 2026
• Jason Mantzoukas January 20 – February 15, 2026
• Craig Robinson January 20 – February 15, 2026
• Sarah Silverman January 20 – February 15, 2026
• Nicholas Braun February 17 – March 8, 2026
• Ashley Park February 17 – March 8, 2026